Recently a teen shared a situation that happened in her math class. She said that her teacher called on a young lady to answer a question. When she didn't know the answer, the teacher reportedly became frustrated and asked the student to stand up and explain why she didn't know the answer. The teacher said she was going to write a three-page essay explaining why she didn't know the answer and then informed her that she needed her mom's phone number so she could call and discuss this with her. She capped off the lecture with, "It looks like you need to go back to middle school."
Perhaps some of these details would be reported differently from a different witness to the event. I don't know, because I wasn't there myself. However, here's what I do know.
It is NEVER productive to humiliate and embarrass others when trying to inspire them to perform better.
If showing good manners means that we act and speak in a way that shows value to others, then embarrassing them would be the complete opposite of that goal.
Once we engage in this type of behavior, we lose the respect of those around us. Without respect, we can't motivate others, people don't care whether they please us or not, and we can't inspire people to want to change. We cripple our ability to lead others to succeed when we don't have their respect and admiration.
We all have wonderful memories of teachers, youth leaders, and adult friends who truly inspired us, made us want to work harder, study more, and achieve greater things. What was so special about them? For me, they were the teachers, leaders, and parents that I knew cared about me and want me to achieve, learn and grow. They bent over backwards to help me succeed.
Whether we're teaching, parenting, or working in any position of leadership, we must ask ourselves why we're here.
Do we really care and want to help, inspire, motivate, and change?
If so, remember to always use respect and honor to those around us. We'll never receive what we're not willing to give.